Is Press Freedom under Threat? AP punished for independent Journalism

During his first term, US President Trump had multiple clashes with the media. Now, another dispute has emerged, this time with the news agency AP. The dispute arose after AP refused to adopt the Trump administration's preferred terminology.

White House excludes AP reporters 

The Associated Press (AP) claims that President Trump’s administration barred two of its reporters from covering White House events. According to AP the exclusion was a result of its refusal to adopt the White House’s preferred terminology, which renamed the Gulf of Mexico to the "Gulf of America."

Julie Pace, AP’s editor-in-chief, condemned the decision in her statement, calling it an attack on the agency’s editorial independence. "It is alarming that the Trump administration is punishing AP for its independent journalism," Pace stated. She emphasized that restricting AP’s access to the Oval Office undermines the public’s right to independent news and violates the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution.

AP clarified that while the name change applies within the U.S., other countries are not required to use the term "Gulf of America." The name "Gulf of Mexico" has been in use for over 400 years, and AP’s global style guide ensures clarity for its worldwide audience. AP style is also not only used by the agency. It is relied on by thousands of journalists and other writers globally.

"White House cannot dictate how the media reports"

The White House Correspondents’ Association (WHCA) expressed strong opposition to the ban. "The White House cannot dictate how news organizations report, nor should it punish individual journalists simply because it disagrees with their editorial decisions," the association said in a statement, offering its support to AP and calling for the reversal of the policy.

While the U.S. government initially remained silent on the matter, reports indicate that some news organizations had been removed from Pentagon office spaces earlier.

AP sticks to the term "Gulf of Mexico"

AP maintains that it will continue using the term "Gulf of Mexico," as it adheres to a global standard for clarity in journalism. This standard, which is outlined in AP’s style guide, includes decisions on spelling, word choices, and reporting principles. Following Trump’s executive order to rename the Gulf, AP reaffirmed its commitment to the established name.

In contrast, Google Maps and Apple Maps both adopted the "Gulf of America" name, citing a longstanding practice of following U.S. government directives.

AP sues the Trump administration

The agency, a non-profit news organization established in 1846, described the White House’s action as a “targeted attack” that undermines both press freedom and the public’s right to speak openly without fear of government retaliation.

In response to its exclusion from White House events, AP filed a lawsuit in federal court, accusing three Trump staff members of violating the First Amendment. The agency argues that denying access to the Oval Office and Air Force One, as well as other White House events, infringes on press freedom.

AP’s complaint underscores its right to editorial independence and its belief that journalists should not be punished for choosing their words freely. The lawsuit aims to protect the press's right to report without government interference, a cornerstone of the U.S. Constitution.

AP urges an end to its White House ban, accusing the Trump administration of further retaliation 

U.S. District Court Judge Trevor N. McFadden denied AP’s request for an injunction to lift the ban on many of its reporters and photographers. However, McFadden noted that case law was not in the White House’s favor and encouraged the administration to reconsider before a second hearing on March 20.

The Associated Press is once again asking a federal judge to restore its access to presidential events, claiming the Trump White House is retaliating for the outlet’s refusal to follow the president’s executive order renaming the Gulf of Mexico.

In an amended lawsuit, AP highlighted continued instances of journalists being denied access, including a photographer blocked from documenting Air Force One’s arrival, and the White House’s decision to control membership in the pool that covers the president at smaller events.

The lawsuit argues that AP’s press credentials now offer less access to the White House than those of other press corps members. The White House maintains that it is not blocking AP from reporting but controls access to the president. 

Exclusion of AP and economic consequences

In addition to being excluded from event coverage, AP claims that the administration’s actions have financial consequences, particularly in terms of lost revenue from photos. In the amended lawsuit, the AP claims that a source informed its journalists the ban was extended from just text reporters to photographers, with the specific intent of depriving the agency of the revenue it generates from selling photographs.

Dozens of news organizations, including Trump-supportive outlets like Fox News Channel and Newsmax, signed a letter urging the White House to change its policy.

This dispute underscores ongoing tensions between the Trump administration and the media, with broad implications for press freedom. The outcome of AP’s lawsuit and the administration’s response will significantly impact the relationship between the press and the U.S. government in the future.

Do you find this article helpful? Share it with friends on social media.